When a business is sued, can it turn away the plaintiff’s lawyer at the door? Madison Square Garden has answered yes for years, and a new Manhattan case shows how the policy plays out.
The Latest Letter
On September 28, 2026, MSG Entertainment barred the attorneys of Mark David Shirian P.C. from Madison Square Garden, Radio City Music Hall, the Beacon Theatre, The Chicago Theatre and the Infosys Theater at MSG. The reason: the firm represents Nino Ufie in a personal-injury suit filed August 14, 2026, in New York Supreme Court against MSG Arena, LLC, Madison Square Garden Entertainment Corp. and MSG Entertainment Holdings, LLC.
Attorney Mark D. Shirian described the letter in a LinkedIn post, saying it cites concerns about contact with employees and disclosures outside the discovery process, and invokes New York’s Rule 4.2. “A ticket is not a deposition,” he wrote. “I take my professional obligations seriously.”
A Bar That Reaches the Whole Firm
Shirian’s objection goes to scope. The restriction, he noted, reaches every lawyer at the firm, “regardless of their involvement in the case.” In his view, “people should be able to retain counsel willing to pursue their claims without the defendant’s influence over that lawyer’s personal life becoming a consideration.”
MSG sees it differently. According to CourtDocket, MSG has said litigation creates an “inherently adversarial environment.” The company has also said the bar ends once the case does. ESPN reported in 2025 that more than 1,000 lawyers from about 90 firms had been affected since 2022, though MSG disputed that number.
The Legal Backdrop
The policy has been tested in court. According to CourtDocket, a New York trial court judge ruled in June 2023 that the ban violated state anti-discrimination law governing places of public entertainment. On appeal, however, MSG has largely prevailed, with higher courts reversing orders that would have lifted the bans.
That history helps explain why the issue keeps resurfacing. Venues are private businesses with broad latitude over who enters, while plaintiffs’ counsel argue that the practical effect is to penalize lawyers for representing clients.
An Unusual Counter-Offer
The Shirian matter drew attention for what came next. Brooklyn Sports & Entertainment, which operates Barclays Center, invited Shirian and his team to the October 8 Nets-76ers game, an offer first reported by EssentiallySports.
The firm Shirian founded in 2016 handles personal-injury and employment matters, and its website cites multiple seven-figure settlements for his clients. Whatever happens with arena access, the Ufie case itself will be decided by the court.
