The Michigan Supreme Court has refused to hear an appeal from dozens of counties and townships challenging how state regulators carry out Michigan’s 2023 renewable energy siting law, leaving in place a lower-court ruling that upheld most of the rules. The justices did agree to hear one narrower dispute over a 30-day deadline that affects when local governments can keep large projects under local review.
The order, issued Nov. 20, 2026, in In re Implementing Provisions of Public Act 233 of 2023, denies the local governments’ application for leave to appeal a May 7, 2026, decision by the Michigan Court of Appeals.
The Law at Issue
Public Act 233 lets developers of large solar, wind and battery storage projects seek approval from the Michigan Public Service Commission when local rules are more restrictive than the law allows, or when local permitting stalls or ends in denial. Communities can keep projects at the local level by adopting a “compatible renewable energy ordinance” whose standards on setbacks, height, fencing and noise are no stricter than the statute’s.
The commission issued implementation guidelines in October 2024, and a coalition of 79 local governments challenged them in court that November. Their main objection was the commission’s position that a compatible ordinance may contain only the standards listed in the statute and nothing more. The Court of Appeals upheld that interpretation in May but struck down two narrower provisions.
What Stands After the Order
By declining review, the Supreme Court ended the local governments’ remaining challenges to the core of the guidelines. It also left untouched the parts of the appellate ruling that went against regulators, including the holding that an “affected local unit” covers any local government with part of a project within its boundaries, not only the one with zoning authority over the site.
Clean energy trade groups welcomed the order, while lawyers for the communities said they were disappointed but highlighted the broader definition of affected local units. The commission has received 13 applications for state approval so far, according to MLive, and approved a settlement in August allowing a 600-acre solar farm in Ingham County to proceed.
The Deadline Fight Still Ahead
The justices granted argument on cross-appeals from the commission and industry groups concerning MCL 460.1223(3). The commission had concluded that a developer may treat a community as lacking a compatible ordinance if the local chief elected official does not respond within 30 days of an offer to meet. The Court of Appeals reversed that finding.
The parties must address whether the appellate court gave the commission’s reading proper deference, whether reversal was wrong, and whether a different rule should apply when a meeting never happens or is unreasonably delayed. Opening briefs are due Dec. 11, responses Dec. 28 and replies Jan. 4, 2027, with argument set for the court’s January 2027 session.
Sources
- Michigan Supreme Court: Order in In re Implementing Provisions of Public Act 233 of 2023 (Nov. 20, 2026)
- MLive: Michigan Supreme Court won’t hear fight against siting rules for big wind, solar farms
- Michigan Public: Michigan Supreme Court upholds renewable energy law over townships’ challenge
- WILX: Michigan Supreme Court declines local challenge to renewable energy rules, will hear deadline dispute
