Lawyers’ Amazon Test Buys Can’t Create Jurisdiction Over Online Sellers, Third Circuit Rules

A seller cannot haul online competitors into a Pennsylvania courtroom simply because its own lawyers ordered their products to a Pittsburgh office, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled on November 20, 2026.

The precedential decision in Promier Products Inc. v. Gearoz, written by Circuit Judge Stephanos Bibas and joined by Judges Thomas Hardiman and Marjorie Rendell, addresses a tactic common in large online-marketplace lawsuits: using “test buys” to establish that a defendant did business in the forum state.

Flashlights Shipped to a Law Firm

Promier, an Illinois company that sells flashlights on Amazon, suspected rival sellers were overstating how bright their products were. It hired a Pittsburgh law firm, which bought competing flashlights on Amazon and had them delivered to its office. Promier alleged that more than three-quarters of them put out less than 1% of the advertised lumens.

Promier then sued 153 China-based sellers in a single case in the Western District of Pennsylvania, asserting false advertising under the Lanham Act and state law. It won an ex parte temporary restraining order that froze bank accounts and marketplace access. After several dozen defendants appeared and objected, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville reconsidered and denied a preliminary injunction, finding personal jurisdiction unlikely.

Why the Test Buys Fell Short

The Third Circuit agreed with that core conclusion. False-advertising claims, the court explained, grow out of sales to consumers who were actually misled. Promier’s lawyers were not deceived about the flashlights, so their purchases could not supply the link between the defendants’ Pennsylvania contacts and the claims. Nationwide Amazon listings alone are not contacts aimed specifically at Pennsylvania.

The panel also held that a plaintiff seeking a preliminary injunction must show a reasonable likelihood that the court has personal jurisdiction, and that a judge does not have to accept the plaintiff’s jurisdictional allegations as true at that stage. The court noted that such injunctions put real pressure on defendants and can push them toward settlement.

A Second Chance on Remand

Promier did not walk away empty-handed. The appeals court vacated the order and sent the case back so the trial judge can decide whether some defendants forfeited their jurisdictional objection by answering the complaint or seeking relief without pressing the issue. For those defendants, the injunction request must be reconsidered on the merits.

For the rest, the court said jurisdictional discovery or an evidentiary hearing may be appropriate, since claims of additional Pennsylvania sales are not frivolous. To ultimately prevail on jurisdiction, Promier will need to prove at least one sale to a deceived Pennsylvania consumer.

Sources