A federal judge in Manhattan has declined to halt New York City’s plan to open publicly funded grocery stores that sell everyday staples at a steep discount, ruling that independent grocers challenging the program had not shown it was likely to break federal antitrust law.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon denied a preliminary injunction on Friday, Nov. 20, in a lawsuit brought by the National Supermarket Association and two grocery businesses against the city and the New York City Economic Development Corporation. The grocers had asked the court to stop the city from selecting private operators for the stores while the case moves forward.
The Program Under Challenge
Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration announced the N.Y.C. Groceries initiative in July. It calls for five stores, one in each borough, that will be publicly funded but run day to day by private operators. Each must sell a core basket of groceries, including produce, meat and seafood, at an average of 30% below typical retail prices, while other items are sold at ordinary prices.
The first locations are planned for East Harlem and Hunts Point in the Bronx, with the Bronx store targeted to open by the end of 2027. The plaintiffs say dozens of nearby independent grocers could be affected.
Why the Injunction Failed
The grocers, who sued in September, alleged attempted monopolization and conspiracy to monopolize under the Sherman Act, arguing that tax-subsidized stores would use below-cost pricing to push neighborhood competitors out of business.
Predatory-pricing claims generally require proof that the defendant can later recoup its losses by charging monopoly prices once rivals are gone. Rochon assumed, without deciding, that the discounted prices could fall below competitors’ average variable costs, but she concluded the plaintiffs could not show a dangerous probability of recoupment. She pointed to the program’s continuing discount requirement, its rules for pricing other goods and the city’s lack of a profit motive.
The judge also rejected the idea that taxpayer backing should excuse the recoupment requirement, warning that such a rule would undercut antitrust laws designed to protect consumers. She added that the balance of hardships and the public interest, including food affordability and access, weighed against blocking the program.
What Comes Next
The ruling is not a final judgment, and the lawsuit remains pending. Counsel for the plaintiffs said they intend to press forward and are reviewing their options. A separate class action filed in August in state court by a coalition representing small grocers and bodega owners raises similar concerns about the program’s effect on local businesses.
Sources
- Courthouse News Service: NYC grocery stores lose bid to halt city-subsidized supermarkets
- Crain’s New York Business: Mamdani’s city-owned grocery stores win in federal court
- Bloomberg Law: Mamdani’s NYC-Owned Grocery Program Can Proceed, Judge Rules
- JBizNews: Judge Rejects Bid to Halt Operator Selection for NYC’s Discount Grocery Stores
