A federal appeals court on Friday, Nov. 20, put on hold a judge’s order requiring the government to help return an Egyptian man who was deported to Equatorial Guinea despite an immigration judge’s finding that he could not be sent to Egypt.
In a brief, unsigned order in A.M.A.S. v. Mullin, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit granted the government’s motion for a stay pending appeal. The panel listed the four factors courts weigh in deciding whether to grant a stay and said they favored the government, but it offered no further explanation. Judge Susan Graber dissented in large part.
Removed to a Third Country
According to the dissent, which drew its account from the district court’s findings, the man came to the United States in 1998 and became a lawful permanent resident in 2021. After convictions for aggravated assault and possession of a synthetic narcotic, the government sought to deport him. In 2025, an immigration judge ordered him removed to Egypt but granted deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture, finding he would likely be tortured there. The government did not appeal.
On April 28, 2026, the government instead flew him to Equatorial Guinea. He was told of the destination shortly before the flight, and when he asked for an interview to raise fear of harm there, he was told it was too late. Judge Graber wrote that he was later held under armed guard, beaten, threatened at gunpoint, and held incommunicado.
The District Court’s Ruling
On Oct. 6, a federal judge in Arizona held that removing him to a third country without notice or a meaningful chance to raise a fear-based claim violated his Fifth Amendment right to due process. The court ordered the government to facilitate his return, relying on the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Noem v. Abrego Garcia, and then issued more detailed follow-up orders. A motions panel had already granted a temporary administrative stay before Friday’s ruling.
The Dissent
Judge Graber agreed that some of the later orders went too far by micromanaging the government’s dealings with a foreign country, and she would have paused those. But she would have left the basic order to facilitate his return in effect while the appeal is pending.
She concluded that the government had not satisfied any of the stay factors. In her view, bringing back one person does not cause the government irreparable harm, and she distinguished the Supreme Court’s earlier stay in DHS v. D.V.D., which involved a classwide challenge to a nationwide program. She also found the government unlikely to win its jurisdictional argument under binding Ninth Circuit precedent.
What Comes Next
The stay leaves the return order on hold while the government’s appeal moves forward.
