Divided Fifth Circuit Says House Proxy Voting Violated Constitution in Passing 2022 Spending Law

A sharply split federal appeals court ruled on Friday, Nov. 20, that the U.S. House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it relied on pandemic-era proxy voting to pass a $1.7 trillion government funding package in December 2022.

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, sitting in New Orleans, voted 9-8 to uphold an injunction obtained by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. That order prevents federal authorities from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which was included in the spending bill, against the state of Texas.

The Proxy Voting Rule

The House adopted proxy voting in May 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, under then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi. The emergency rule allowed members to authorize colleagues to cast votes for them instead of appearing on the floor. Republicans dropped the practice after winning the House majority in the 2022 midterm elections.

Before that change, the House used the rule to approve the omnibus spending law, which passed 225-201 with 226 members voting by proxy. President Joe Biden signed it, including the pregnant-worker provision, which strengthened workplace accommodation rights for pregnant employees.

The Majority’s Reasoning

Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Cory Wilson concluded that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present in order to conduct business such as passing legislation. Although each chamber has broad power to set its own procedures, he wrote, Congress cannot use its rules to sidestep the limits the Quorum Clause places on its authority.

Despite finding a problem with how the whole bill passed, the court’s remedy was limited. It only bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant-worker law against Texas.

A Pointed Dissent

Circuit Judge James Graves dissented, calling the majority’s decision “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.” He argued the Quorum Clause contains no physical-presence requirement and that the majority had invented one. Graves also questioned why, if the entire law was passed unconstitutionally, the remedy should reach only one narrow piece of a multitrillion-dollar measure.

Neither the Justice Department nor Paxton’s office responded to requests for comment. The closely divided vote and the constitutional stakes make the case a likely candidate for review by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Sources