Tenant Groups File Class Action to Block HUD Rule Targeting Mixed-Status Immigrant Families

A coalition of public housing tenants and housing rights organizations has sued the federal government in Boston, seeking to stop a new Department of Housing and Urban Development rule that advocates say will force many immigrant families to either split up or give up their subsidized homes.

The federal class action was filed Thursday, Nov. 19, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, one week after HUD published the rule on Nov. 12. The regulation is scheduled to take effect Dec. 14.

What the New Rule Changes

For roughly 30 years, HUD has allowed so-called mixed-status households, where some members are eligible for federal housing aid and others are not, to live together and receive a prorated subsidy. The ineligible family member simply receives no assistance, and the household pays more rent as a result.

The new rule ends that arrangement. Families would have to remove the ineligible person from the household or lose the subsidy entirely. Advocates note that in most affected homes, the ineligible members are parents and the eligible members are minor children who are U.S. citizens, meaning the practical result is that whole families must move out.

Once the rule is in force, local housing authorities would send notices requiring mixed-status families to verify the eligibility of every household member within 90 days. The rule also adds documentation requirements for all assisted tenants, including citizens, which tenant leaders say will be especially hard on elderly and disabled residents.

The Legal Claims

The plaintiffs argue the rule violates the Administrative Procedure Act and the due process protections of the Fifth Amendment, and that HUD breached its obligation under the Fair Housing Act to work against discrimination. The complaint also ties the rule to the administration’s broader effort to test the limits of the Supreme Court’s birthright citizenship decision issued this summer.

Three anonymous plaintiffs come from mixed-status families. One is a Massachusetts mother who has lived in the U.S. since 2015 and is authorized to live and work there, but whose status is not among those that qualify for housing aid. Three of her four children are U.S. citizens.

Organizational plaintiffs include the Mass Union of Public Housing Tenants, the Fall River Housing Authority Joint Tenants’ Council, Border Workers United and the Smith Houses Resident Association.

Background

The administration pursued a similar policy during President Trump’s first term. This version drew more than 13,000 public comments nationwide. Tenant advocates also point out that HUD provided no funding to help local housing authorities handle the added verification work.

Sources