Federal Judge Strikes Down Trump Administration’s Transgender Limits on Ryan White HIV Funding

A federal judge in Boston has struck down Trump administration conditions that barred clinics receiving certain federal HIV-care money from recognizing transgender patients’ gender identities or providing them gender-affirming treatment.

The Decision

U.S. District Judge William Young issued a 165-page ruling on Thursday, November 19, after a non-jury trial held in September. He sided with the American Academy of HIV Medicine, the HIV Medicine Association, the International Association of Providers of AIDS Care and individual providers, who challenged the rules in a case represented by Lambda Legal.

According to Lambda Legal, the court declared the conditions unlawful, vacated them, and permanently barred the government from applying them or similar policies to the plaintiff groups’ members, a group the organization says includes nearly every HIV care provider in the country.

What the Conditions Required

The restrictions applied to the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program, which Congress created in 1990 to fund medical care for low-income and uninsured people living with HIV. Starting in March, the Health Resources and Services Administration, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, added grant terms meant to carry out President Trump’s executive order directing the government to recognize only two sexes.

Under those terms, grantees had to ensure funds supported activities using “sex-based definitions grounded in biological reality” rather than what the government called social or medical experimentation. The plaintiffs argued the rules clashed with the program’s mandate to provide comprehensive care, which has historically included hormone therapy for transgender patients.

The Constitutional Findings

Young, an appointee of President Ronald Reagan, found the conditions violated the First Amendment because they were aimed at suppressing ideas the administration disfavored, penalizing doctors for acknowledging transgender people and using patients’ chosen pronouns. He also held that the rules amounted to sex discrimination barred by the Fifth Amendment.

The opinion closed in unusually pointed terms. “They are based in animus, loathing, and discrimination,” Young wrote of the conditions. “They do not stand for justice — in fact, they defy it.”

What Comes Next

Lambda Legal attorney Jose Abrigo called the result a sweeping merits victory. HHS did not immediately comment, and an appeal to the First Circuit is possible. The ruling arrives amid a wider legal fight over the administration’s transgender policies, some of which, including the military service ban and passport restrictions, the Supreme Court has allowed to take effect.

Sources